PHI 4903H - HON DIRECT RDG I
Section: 0201
College of Arts and Humanities
Department of Philosophy

Course Information

Term: Spring 2026
Class Meeting Days: ASC
Class Meeting Location: 
Modality: P
Credit Hours: 3.00

Instructor Information

Name: Jonathan Beever
Title: Professor of Ethics & Digital Cultures
Office Location: HPH 116G
Office Hours

Thursdays 12-1 and by appointment

Phone: 3-4340
Email: Jonathan.Beever@ucf.edu

These HUT thesis hours are intended for you to work with Dr. Beever, per our HUT agreement, on thesis research and planning.

Student Learning Outcomes

After successful completion of this course, students will be able to:

  • situate their thesis idea in the context of existing scholarly work in philosophy and elsewhere
  • identify a clear and coherent outline for an HUT thesis
  • use their planning and research to begin thesis writing toward a defense.

Required Course Materials and Resources

none required

Course Assessment and Grading Procedure

These thesis research hours will be graded pass/fail, based on the progress completed toward the thesis.

Assignment Schedule

Due Date Assignment Name Assignment Type Points
1/12/26
Quiz
0

Grading Scale

These hours will be graded pass/fail.

Policies for Course Grade

"Passing" these hours requires regular meetings with Dr. Beever for which you are prepared, substantial and regular progress on thesis research, and evidence of planning to write the thesis (outlining, section drafting, concept mapping, etc).

Artificial Intelligence (AI) Use Policy

Use of "AI" tools:

I am generally wary of the use of LLMs and their generative platforms for academic work, and I encourage you too to be wary. My reasons are outlined in the paragraphs of this section that follow.[1]  Thus it is my preference that your work in this class will not be supported by these tools unless directly instructed by me. However, I recognize how pervasive these tools are becoming, both professionally and within the university. So, if your work is in any way so supported by generative platforms, I require that you make that way explicit to me through an extended footnote to whatever writing or work was so supported. Specifically, I want to know which tools, what prompts, and how your evaluation and revision process proceeded. Apart from instances of direct plagiarism (taking a generated prompt and treating it as your own writing/work), there will be no penalty for your use of generative platforms, provided their use is clearly and explicitly documented in the assignment.

 

How do generative AI platforms work?

ChatGPT and other generative AI platforms like it are built on large language models (LLMs). Basically, these tools have scraped billions or trillions of data points and have been trained to build statistically probable responses to prompts. For written prompts and responses, they do so at a sentence level (next logical sentence given the one it just created) and at the word level (next logical word given the rest of the sentence so far). Thus, these tools are very good at providing a seemingly logical or coherent answer to any question. But it is not "thinking" as it gives each answer; it is providing a likely combination of words of sentences based on those used in its training. A good analogy is a parrot, which can mimic words but has no clue what it's actually saying. However, these systems can outright invent facts, names, quotes, and book/journal/article titles and present them in a confident tone as it does so.

When should I use generative AI platforms? When should I avoid it?

First, recognize that generative AI platforms do not verify the responses they give. They may provide incorrect facts and must never be trusted "out of the box." Although AI tools can be useful to help you brainstorm or get an overview on a topic, you should compare AI-generated responses to expert sources. Second, be aware that UCF faculty and the university do not and should not have a single unified reaction to these tools. One of your professor’s primary goals is to train you to be the best in your profession. Some professions embrace LLMs in their current form while others prohibit their use. There are unsettled ethical, legal, and societal issues raised by AI. Your faculty will adopt teaching and assessment policies that help you understand those issues, so you are best prepared for your profession, including changes it will inevitably undergo as AI evolves. As a result, some faculty will allow you to incorporate AI output in your submission, or even require it. Others may ban it partially or completely. Consult with the professor about what's allowed, and/or look for details in the syllabus. Third, recognize that others may not want their ideas, their writing, or their work entered into an AI platform without their permission. Someone else’s writing contains their ideas and their intellectual property, and authors may not want to disclose their work. For example, you should get permission before entering your classmates’ writing or your professor’s lectures into an AI chatbot. Additionally, you should take great care that when you prompt a chatbot that you do not to enter someone else’s personal information or a client’s proprietary data as you may not be able to control how that information is used or stored by the LLM – regardless of access level or platform policy. Lastly, be sure that you do not simply submit an output from any generative platforms as if you wrote those words. To do so is clearly and unarguably plagiarism, and you are putting your academic future at risk. The purpose of an academic assignment/project is for you to learn. Taking a shortcut on this process impacts the learning goals for the course/program/degree.

How about online tests? Can I use generative platforms for help?

Obviously, the answer is no. Tests are meant to measure your recall, application, analysis, or other type of performance in a limited time span. Tests are not meant to measure your ability to look something up. We understand that all students want to do well on an exam; however, what is most important is that you learn the subject and are able to demonstrate what you have learned on a test. Should there be something that you have misunderstood, the instructor will mark an answer as wrong and/or give feedback. By using AI, it is unclear what you have learned compared to what you simply copied as your answer. We want all students to graduate from UCF with the confidence that they mastered a subject and earned a degree that represents their readiness to be a proud Knight in the working community. Shortcutting this experience can impact your academic growth as well as your standing at the university.

What's the big deal? AI is here to stay, so why is it bad for me to use it?

It's true that “artificial intelligence” may be here to stay, and it's also true that many workplaces of the future are likely to include AI in some fashion. However, your professors are making assignments to test your prowess in using AI; instead, they have different learning goals in mind. Usually, this involves some version of critical thinking as it relates to their discipline. College is not here to just grant you a diploma so you can get a job; college aims to train your mind so that you will be successful in your career. When you take shortcuts to the idea of training your mind, you are literally cheating yourself.



[1] These paragraphs are adapted excerpts from a 2024 email to UCF students authored by Kevin Ye (FCTL/AI for All) and Laurie Pinkert (Department of Writing and Rhetoric).

Disability Access & Accommodations

The University of Central Florida is committed to providing equal access to all students with disabilities (ADHD, learning disabilities, Autism, chronic medical conditions, physical disabilities, etc.). To receive consideration for reasonable disability-related course accommodations, disabled students must contact Student Accessibility Services (SAS) and complete the steps required for SAS to review accommodation requests. More information can be found on the UCF Student Accessibility Services website under the Start Here tab or by contacting SAS directly (Ferrell Commons 185; sas@ucf.edu; Phone - 407-823-2371).

Approved accommodations are shared with course instructors via the SAS Course Accessibility Letter. Implementing certain accommodations may require discussion about specific considerations of the course design, course learning objectives, and the individual academic and course challenges experienced by the student. While students with disabilities or chronic health needs are also encouraged to discuss any course concerns with professors in addition to contacting SAS, professors are not required to facilitate disability-related adjustments to the course unless the professor has received a Course Accessibility Letter from SAS that outlines approved accommodations.

Academic Integrity

Students should familiarize themselves with UCF's Code of Conduct at Student Conduct and Integrity Office. According to Section 1, "Academic Misconduct," students are prohibited from engaging in:

  1. Academic misconduct is defined as any submitted work or behavior that obstructs the instructor of record's ability to accurately assess the student's understanding or completion of course materials or degree requirements (e.g., assignment, quiz, and/or exam). Examples of academic misconduct include but are not limited to: plagiarism, unauthorized assistance to complete an academic exercise; unauthorized communication with others during an examination, course assessment, or project; falsifying or misrepresenting academic work; providing misleading information to create a personal advantage to complete course/degree requirements; or multiple submission(s) of academic work without permission of the instructor of record.
  2. Any student who knowingly helps another violate academic behavior standards is also in violation of the standards.
  3. Commercial Use of Academic Material. Selling of course material to another person and/or uploading course material to a third-party vendor without authorization or without the express permission of the University and the instructor of record. Course materials include but are not limited to class notes, the instructor of record's slide deck, tests, quizzes, labs, instruction sheets, homework, study guides, and handouts.
  4. Soliciting assistance with academic coursework and/or degree requirements. The solicitation of assistance with an assignment, lab, quiz, test, paper, etc., without authorization of the instructor of record or designee is prohibited. This includes but is not limited to asking for answers to a quiz, trading answers, or offering to pay another to complete an assignment. It is considered Academic Misconduct to solicit assistance with academic coursework and/or degree requirements, even if the solicitation did not yield actual assistance (for example, if there was no response to the solicitation).

Responses to Academic Dishonesty, Plagiarism, or Cheating

Students should also familiarize themselves with the procedures for academic misconduct in UCF's student handbook, The Golden Rule. UCF faculty members have a responsibility for students' education and the value of a UCF degree, and so seek to prevent unethical behavior and respond to academic misconduct when necessary. Penalties for violating rules, policies, and instructions within this course can range from a zero on the exercise to an "F" letter grade in the course. In addition, an Academic Misconduct report could be filed with the Office of Student Conduct and Academic Integrity, which could lead to disciplinary warning, disciplinary probation, or deferred suspension or separation from the University through suspension, dismissal, or expulsion with the addition of a "Z" designated on one's transcript.

Being found in violation of academic conduct standards could result in a student having to disclose such behavior on a graduate school application, being removed from a leadership position within a student organization, the recipient of scholarships, participation in University activities such as study abroad, internships, etc.

Let's avoid all of this by demonstrating values of honesty, trust, and integrity. No grade is worth compromising your integrity and moving your moral compass. Stay true to doing the right thing: take the zero, not a shortcut.

Title IX

Title IX prohibits sex discrimination, including sexual misconduct, sexual violence, sexual harassment, and retaliation. If you or someone you know has been harassed or assaulted, you can find resources available to support the victim, including confidential resources and information concerning reporting options at Let's Be Clear and UCF Cares.

For more information on access and community engagement, Title IX, accessibility, or UCF's complaint processes contact:

Reporting an Incident or Issue

If you believe you have experienced discrimination by any faculty or staff member, contact the Office of Nondiscrimination & Accommodations Compliance via the ONAC website or at 407-823-1336. You can also choose to report using the UCF Integrity Line either anonymously or as yourself at 1-855-877-6049 or by using the online form. UCF cares about you and takes every report seriously. For more information see the Reporting an Incident or Issue Webpage.

Deployed Active-Duty Military Students

Students who are deployed active-duty military and/or National Guard personnel and require accommodation should contact their instructors as soon as possible after the semester begins and/or after they receive notification of deployment to make arrangements.

Campus Safety

At UCF's Public Safety and Police, safety is the top priority. Emergencies on campus are rare, but if one should arise, it's important to be familiar with some basic safety and security concepts.

  • In an emergency, always dial 911.
  • Every UCF Classroom has an Emergency Procedure Guide posted on a wall near the door, which will show you how to respond to a variety of situations. This guide can also be found online here.
  • In the event of an active threat, remember AVOID, DENY, DEFEND. Choose the best course of action and act immediately. Watch the video here to learn more.
    • AVOID. Pay attention to your surroundings and have an exit plan. Get as much distance and as many barriers between you and the threat as quickly as possible.
    • DENY. When avoiding is difficult or impossible, deny the threat access to you and your space. Lockdown by creating barriers, turning the lights off and remaining quiet and out of sight. Make sure your phone is silenced, but do not turn it off.
    • DEFEND. When you are unable to put distance between yourself and the threat, be prepared to protect yourself. Commit to your actions, be aggressive and do not fight fairly. Do whatever it takes to survive.
  • For emergencies on campus, UCF will utilize the UCF Alert system. All UCF students, faculty, and staff are automatically enrolled to receive these email and text alerts, however, it's a good idea to frequently ensure your contact information is up to date.

Financial Aid Accountability

All instructors are required to document students' academic activity at the beginning of each course. In order to document that you began this course, please complete this activity by the end of the first week of classes or as soon as possible after adding the course. Failure to do so may result in a delay in the disbursement of your financial aid.

Class Schedule

WeekTopic
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Course Schedule